Wednesday, April 28, 2021

Tom Cook (Hanna-Barbera/Filmation/Ruby-Spears show animator, 70s/80s) Interview Notes

Notes from the A Podcast Named Scooby-Doo! interview with Tom Cook. It can be listened at http://scoobydoocast.libsyn.com/42-interview-with-tom-cook. Here are some notes I have taken of the interview that fills out details of being a stateside TV animator in the 1980s.

Tom Cook's run as an assistant animator at Hanna Barbera went uncredited.

He loved superhero comics, especially of Marvel (Spiderman)

He drew while growing up, but never thought he could work in comic books. He only liked drawing the characters and not the backgrounds, which is what he thought that the job would entail, with drawing both.

Grew up with early HB cartoons, 10 years old in early 60s

Especially loved Top Cat because TC initials matched his name.

He knew nothing about the animation industry or how to get in.

Was a transit bus driver in Los Angeles, went past the Hanna-Barbera building 2-3 times a day on his route.

Late 77/early 78: Day-off, got mail during lunch, pamphlet of extension classes for Cal-State Northridge 

Summer Comic book class offered

Interested in comic books

Don Rico was teacher

Tom Cook recognized him for Captain America, he wanted to meet him.

Signed up for the class

His portfolio for the class at the time consisted of Fantastic Four, Spider-Man, Marvel

Rico (Story Director/storyboard artist for HB at the time) recommended Cook for a Thursday Night basic animation class at the HB studio taught by Harry Love to get him on Challenge of the Superfriends based on his good superhero artwork. Lack of animators at HB who could draw the realistic figures.

Harry Love was impressed with Cook's portfolio as well and called in Joe Barbera to see it as well. Barbera was also impressed and would guarantee that Cook would get a job when they would be done constructing a new building in the studio with more available room. This was the only notable interaction Cook had with Barbera, besides one other time at a company party.

4 out of 30 students were selected at the end of the class after three weeks, which included Tom Cook.

His first shows were The New Fred and Barney Show, Challenge of the SuperFriends, Scooby and Scrappy-Doo, Scooby Goes to Hollywood, Kwicky Koala, some opening credit scenes and some commercials that promoted the HB series. He was always in the assistant animator role at HB.

His first assistant scene was in the New Fred and Barney Show episode Haunted Inheritance when Fred is jumping all around Dino of his excitement of getting the inheritance. He got a cel of his very first drawing in the scene with a background.


As seen in the episode. Not the cel.

He was the assistant (inbetweener/clean-up) animator to Rick Leon. Leon was really nice and patient to him, he realized that Cook was totally new to the job, and so never give Cook anything above his current skill level and provided detailed explanations to him on some of the harder scenes to do.

The full animators would draw in a light blue pencil that would get redrawn in a black pencil by the assistant animators such as Cook to prepare the drawings to be Xeroxed onto a cel, and to make an on-model clean-up of the rough animation by the full animator.

Full animators also set up a timing chart after figuring out the movement of the scene, which indicated where the inbetweens would go, which Cook also did.

Cook would say that it took him the first six months for him to fully realize animation and do a good job.

Cook would learn and study about the full animator's thought process and timing while as an assistant.

He became a full animator within the first three years of his career at another studio.

There was no choice of what show the assistants would be on in one given week. Assistants would try to endure the work on a show they didn't like and waited to get to the good shows, but the timing had to be right. There was nothing Cook worked on that bothered him. He found every show he was given to be new and exciting to work on.

 Assistant animators didn't meet with their directors because the work had already been animated by the full animator. When assistants would run out of work, they would go to either their full animator if the animator's scene had been completed enough for the assistant to do their pass on or to the other animators for more work if their scene wasn't ready for the assistants yet.

He worked on the Groove sequence in Scooby Goes to Hollywood. He kept the drawings and redid one of them in color to give to Henry Winkler, who was the original Fonzie that the Groove was parodying. 

Cook idolized David Tendlar at the studio due to his long experience and so went to learn from him as well. Tendlar was very short, in his late 60s, always wore a bow tie, dressed very good compared to the other animators who just wore blue jeans and t-shirts. He would always take the time and help Cook on his scenes. Cook also asked Tendlar for advice on harder scenes.

Jack Kirby was at HB also as a designer, another of Cook's heroes. When Cook first saw him walking between two of the buildings at a bridge, he stopped Kirby at the bridge. Kirby took his portfolio down, and the two sat down and talked for twenty minutes.

He maintained good relations with Bill Hanna, who was very friendly to him. Even when Tom Cook was at Baer Animation, Hanna still came over to celebrate the anniversary of the studio with Dale Baer. He talked with Hanna the most out of the HB leaders.

Cook recalled that Iwao Takamoto would day in his office all day and would not walk around to meet with other artists. He never made contact with Takamoto as a result.

George Singer was the best friend of Cook's dad. Cook got in good contact with him with that.

Cook saw Tex Avery from time to time. He was quiet and unassuming.

Any animator in their 40s onwards would help Cook on whatever problem he was struggling with when he came in their rooms. Cook felt that he did not meet many nasty people at the studios. He assumes that it was in their personalities to he helpful to the younger animators.

Cook feels that the veteran animators were so busy with the workload that they had to hire new animators with no experience in animation such as him by 1978. He feels that some of the new animators really should not have had the job. In the 60s, they wouldn't had to resort to this. Full animators were not encouraged to do their own inbetweens because they were encouraged by the studio to focus on the movement in the next scenes due to their talent being sought out, and leave it to others to finish the scenes up.

For all the studios he was at, the schedule was to start at 8:30, had a 10:30 break, had a 12:30 lunch for an hour, had a 3:30 break, and left at 5:00. It wasn't a union rule, but it was unofficial due to most people being the union anyway. There were no timeclocks, he just came in to the studios.

Cook joined Ruby-Spears for a short time working on Fangface, Plastic Man, and Heathcliff. He and the Heathcliff animation crew was laid-off in 1980 when Mel Blanc participated in a voice acting strike, preventing him from voicing the character. Ruby-Spears never hired the crew back, deciding to send the animator work overseas shortly after. Cook thought that RB were in over their heads.

Cook joined Filmation (as a full animator) when the other studios started rapidly moving to overseas animation. He agreed with Lou Schemer's philosophy that animation should reman in the states and credits him for saving his career as an animator. Cook blames the Animation Guild for wanting more money with pensions and healthcare, that had drove up the cost of network animation to a point that the networks could not afford making the shows anymore, mentioning about the 1982 strike. He used to say "What good does making 50 bucks an hour if you work zero hours?" in response to the Guild's practices.

The Filmation quota for an animator was eighty feet of film per week (1280 frames or 53:08 seconds per week). Animators would have to work on the weekends if they couldn't accomplish the limit during the weekdays. If the animator entered a day too stressed, then they would take a day to coast on the work that would be made up by working hard on the weekends. Some common scenes to get to quota would be a sequence of very short 4 feet scenes with quick cuts, an establishing scene with backgrounds, but with no character animation, but would still be counted among an animator's scene towards their quota. Establishing scenes could last up to 15 feet that an animator would take without having to draw anything within the scene itself. These scenes were given when an animator had other particularly difficult scenes to accomplish and would not be able to meet the quota otherwise. Later on  in Filmation, when the animators were in a crunch, if an animator could do 160 feet a week (2560 feet or equivalent to 1 minute and 46 seconds of footage), the animator would be given two paychecks. If an animator got easy scenes to start off the week with, that would encourage the animators to work on weekends on the hard scenes to get the double paycheck and make extra cash. Contract work also allowed a certain number of scenes ranging in the 25-30 feet range could be done at the animator's home in the evening, in addition to the normal 80 feet quota. Animators also took this option as much as they could get due to the extra money. 

Filmation shows had 10 directors who took the storyboard to do slugging (mathematically timing the length of each scene in the board, so that the time of the episode exactly matches up with each commercial break). The directors pin a number of scenes from the episode that can be completed in a week. They try to then figure out how to give each animator 80 feet worth of scenes to do. But if they give an animator enough scenes, then the animator would have to pick up more scenes from another episode to do to meet quota. Outside the directors' rooms, a little wheel would determine which director the animator would get work from. When the director ran out with giving the animator work, then the wheel would be spun again to determine the next director to pick up the work from. Directors would then announce the take home contract work to any animator who was interested. Younger animators mostly took home the contract work. Veteran animators would deny the opportunity for contract work based on their faster speed that allowed them to meet the quotas more often than the younger animators.


25% percent of all Filmation episodes had to be stock footage to lower the budget enough to allow the in-house animators to compete with overseas animation. Animators had to film mouths and eye blinks to go along with the rest of the already drawn scene.

Tom Cook did the work as a passionate fan of animation, something that he did not see other animators at the time agreeing with, who just treated it as a job. He goes on Comic Cons to represent the generation of animators on He-Man, to imbue others with his passion.









Tuesday, April 27, 2021

Credit the Crew of Mercury Filmworks - Disney TV's Vendor Studio Credit Policy Has to Change

 The new Disney show The Ghost and Molly McGee will debut in October on Disney Channel. 

(16) First Day Frights 👻 | NYCC Sneak Peek | The Ghost and Molly McGee | Disney Channel Animation - YouTube

I was taken aback at how fantastic the show looks and moves in the clip from Comic Con. Mercury Filmworks, the vendor studio, did an absolutely gorgeous job here, from the excellent character acting on Molly to the stunning builds of Scratch, the ghost to the exquisite background work by the layout team of Molly's attic. It's a shame that the all mightily talented crew of character and FX animators, builders and riggers, layout and backgrounds, technical directors, compositors, and scene set-up people who all made this possible will most likely go uncredited for their hard efforts as has been the case on all series that they have contributed towards.

Disney has had a history of shunting out credit to any of their outsourcing studios, of which Mercury Filmworks has been a frequent victim of their misdeeds. Every show that has Disney Television Animation outsource their animation process to Mercury has almost always gone without credit for the Mercury crew. It doesn't matter how excellent or jaw-dropping their quality shows on-screen, the crews of vendor studios are not allowed to receive their deserved credits asides from a top show-encompassing animation supervisor name here and the studio name there. I have always been frustrated with this credits measure from Disney and any other studio that dabbles in this policy.

What follows is the nine total Disney series that have went creditless for the amazing crew at Mercury Filmworks since all the way back to 2010, from Kick Buttowski to Tangled.









Well, at least Disney credited one person out of potenially hundreds of Mercury people on Lion Guard and Mickey. That's real improvement right there.

Ha ha ha, spoke too soon. Christian Larocque was the animation director on the Tangled series also, and Disney somehow couldn't give him the same credit here as in Lion Guard despite being in the same role. They couldn't even manage getting that consistent.

Disney is able to do full credits of Mercury, as they have done so for a single Lion Guard special episode ("Battle for the Pride Lands"), which is even more frustrating because it's not a consistent practice for the other series specials which either are creditless, like the other Lion Guard specials, or use a very truncated list of leads (???) without listing which person did what job as in the Tangled specials.






This is what Disney's credit policy should have been for the past nine series, and the fact that it's only been used on one special and nothing else is saddening.


And we just go back to square one by the next regular episode of the season. Sigh.

This is the credits list that Disney uses for the Tangled special episodes. It's very confusing why it doesn't list out the positions/disciplines of the jobs. Are these people part of builds? Animators? Layout team? We just don't know. It is just so cryptic as to which role these people performed in making these shows beautiful. Sorta useless as credits if you don't give out the necessary information on the specific roles these people played. Also, this is all Mercury gets compared to the Lion Guard Special, this one short-length credits card compared to three long-length credit cards on consecutive screens. Which means that tons of other crew is getting left out altogether.

On Molly McGee, I hope that Disney can come to their senses and give the Mercury crew their due time in the spotlight. Their talent has done some incredible things with each and every Disney series that they have touched for the past eleven years. They should have gotten full credits as early as their first series, Kick Buttowski  for all of their amazing ingenuity and skill. Everyone on a production needs to be recognized for being amazing people who give us such amazing quality for no credit of their own.

The List of Animation Studios/Optical Effects in New York City in 1976

This is the list that I will be using for my feature. From Backstage Magazine issue of August 6, 1976.














 

Sunday, April 11, 2021

(Action Productions, INC.) - 70s New York City Animation Studios

       The Back Stage Magazine of August 6 1976 provided detailed listings of many animation studios in New York City at the time. This series of posts will go by each studio on the list one by one, and will gather every bit of information that I can find about each of these studios and the people who lead them. This is a salute and tribute towards everyone's hard work and bravery while navigating through the turbulent industry in NY. A way to preserve and secure these amazing people's legacies and their amazing artistry.



Action Productions, INC.

Location: 16 W. 46 St.

Projects: Animated productions

Staff: Stop-motion and special effects: John Gati (October 6, 1927 - July 30, 2002), 

Production: Jerry Brownstein

Director: Hal Lippman

"At this studio, John Gati produces fine stop motion effects for various advertiser clients. His latest extravaganza, produced for Scott Grass Seed, will show vegetables growing using time-lapse photography over a period of three months. Five Mitchell camera will record the vegetables' growth one frame at a time. Gati is also starting work on a Polaroid spot that will use a number of effects, including strobe images."

-   Howard Beckerman, Filmmakers: Film and Video Monthly, July 1980, https://asteriskpix.blogspot.com/2010/07/whats-everybody-doing-in-1980.html


"Small Is Beautiful for John Gati at Action Productions

 Two jobs recently completed at New York's Action Productions bear out the Schumacher adage about the Lilliputian view of life : small is beautiful . Using a miniature of a Long John Silvers Restaurant enabled John Gati to get a clean look, with no distracting real life buildings or electrical wires to confuse the picture. Working with Leo Stuckhus, VP of Abbott Advertising in Lexington, Kentucky, who was creative director on the job, Gati injected the four seasons for the openings and closings of commercials advertising the national restaurant chain. Another spot had a 16-inch 112132-type metallic robot in a blue beret-palette in one hand, paintbrush in the other-painting the logo for the Michigan-based People's National Bank & Trust Company. The animated robot, made by well-known Long Island model maker Tom Newberry, was operated by the armature inside and moved frame by frame. "We are back with Lucas and Harryhausen," notes Gati. 'They do that and we do, too ." After completing this spot, Gati flew to last month's international festival of puppet animators held in Odense, Denmark . Among the entries were Gati's "Flutey and the Knights," a pilot for a children's TV series ."

- MILLIMETER/SEPTEMBER 1981 http://www.vasulka.org/archive/RightsIntrvwInstitMediaPolicies/IntrvwInstitKaldron/PaintSystemsSurvey/DigiArt.pdf



"Fast Action For Action Productions

There's a new production company in town called Action Productions, at 16 W. 46 St., 391-2747.

Jerry Brownstein is the production manager.: John Gati, stop motion/special effects; Hal Lipman, Director; Arlene Sang, Representative and Fay Spinelli the General Manager.

If the names sound familiar to you, it's because just last month you probably were calling most of them at Directors Group where you will still find John Ercole and his prod mgr. Jim Allen

There'll be some additions made officially at Director's Group in the near future." 

- Back Stage, Nov 14, 1975


"John Gati, Director of Special Effects for Action Productions, is on camera shooting a special effects sequence of merging water droplets for Phillips' Milk of Magnesia's "Lively People" TV commercial. At far left, Anestos Tritchonis, Art Director/Producer from Dancer-Fitzgerald-Sample, supervised."

- Back Stage, (Mar 26, 1976)


Action Productions President Jerry Brownstein recently prepared his children, Lisa & Karen for their first TV spot. Agency was ITAG Adv.. Mexico City for Del-Campo Chocolates. Agency producer, Matthew Rusti, Director, Hal Lipman and special effects, John Gati.

- Backstage, Oct 7, 1977




"Real 'Stop Action' Takes Weeks of Work

John Gati of Action Productions recently moved to 14 East 39 St., just completed a true stop action commercial for People's National Bank & Trust Co.

Using space models and a special landscape which he designed and built, Mr. Gati completed the commercial in two weeks. Yes that's how long it takes Mr. Gati and his crew of four people to do a real stop action commercial, moving models bit by bit, fraction by fraction.

Agency was Stockwell Marcuse, with Paige C. Curtis, as creative director., Wolf Brucker, Art director., Tom Gibson, account exec. Jerry Brownstein was producer for Action Productions."

- Back Stage, (Jan 23, 1981)

"From (Beck) Underwood: My only formal training in stop motion was in a class at SVA, taught by old school animator John Gati. I modified a porcelain doll into my first animation puppet. The resulting film, That Creepy Old Doll was completed in 1998 and shot on 16mm film. This short travelled to festivals around the world."

http://glasseyepix.com/new-in-the-cinezone-beck-underwoods-creepy-old-doll-trilogy/

"In the area of object and figure animation and stop motion, John Gati, the Director of Special Effects, for Action Pictures in New York is unsurpassed. John has been working at his craft for 26 years and has won many awards for technique and innovation.

The art of Object and Figure Animation requires enormous craftsmanship. Basically, it resembles conventional (drawn) animation in that it follows the rule of “creating the movement” by the process of frame by frame photography. But as opposed to eel animation, which occurs on a two dimensional (acetate) surface, Object Animation is similar to live action photography taking place in a three-dimensional area.

John Gati’s creations succeed in making the product itself (the object) become the hero of the commercial, which is one of the basic tenets of good “sell” advertising. Complicated rigs and special dimensional lighting are required to make this form of animation truly work. It requires enormous intricacy to sustain the fantasy of “life” for these objects. John works with such materials as foams, wires, rubbers, vinyls, plastics, silks, clays and waxes to create the illusion of “reality.” Working in the tradition of the great artists and artisans of the past, John — like McLaren and Trnka and Geesink — has created a wondrous world of living and moving objects that reflect a “life all their own. Among his most recent successes are Fleischman’s “Egg Beaters” and Speidel’s “Faces In the Watch-bands. ”

"1. Object Animation: Speidel’s “Faces In The Watches”
created by John Gati of Action Pictures."


Arthur Ross, Millimeter, 1977, http://www.michaelspornanimation.com/splog/?p=2293


"The result of a twelve week course in stop motion animation at The School of Visual Arts, "(That) Creepy (Old Doll)" is my first 16mm animated film. My instructor, John Gati, provided me with an amazing introduction to the painstaking discipline of stop motion animation. With the help of a little aluminum wire and a lot of patience, I was able to bring to life a few members of my collection of antique dolls and props, as well as create a fantastic little puppet character named Jasper."

-Beck Underwood, http://www.zuzu.org/jasper.html

"SVA, 1993-1996. My personal story with character animation was like a magic dream. I came to America in 1993, and it was a dream come true that I met Mr. John Gati in SVA animation masters class. He loved his class, and I learned so much from him; not only technique and skill, but how to work from the heart to make beautiful characters."

Miwha Lee, https://www.linkedin.com/in/miwha-lee-56a39659/

"Back in the days when I was scouting New York for any possible job in the animation industry, my love of puppet animation came to the rescue.

Through ASIFA East I’d met John Gati and had talked with him through many trips on the subway (we both lived in Queens at the time), about 3D animation. John made his living with model animation for commercials, though his love was full-out puppets. At a dry time for me, he offered 2-3 days work helping him on a commercial spot for Care*Free Sugarless gum.

The Care*Free gum had to undress itself (take off the wrapper) and jump on a scale. Trident gum, did the same on the other end of the scale. Which weighed more? Care*Free, of course.

I prepared the packaged gum, wired it up for 3D movement and helped in the shoot. Just as we were completing the spot, word came down that Trident was changing its package. We had to do the spot again. Another two days of work for me.

Midweek, another spot started on the other side of the studio (a large open room with a lot of cameras, movieolas and equipment. Lou Bunin had just started animating a Lucky Charms commercial with a puppet elf. This was a test commercial General Mills wanted to view to see how the character worked in 3D. (Obviously, they didn’t do the change.)

For a couple of days, I got to watch and talk with Lou seeing how real characters were animated. It was memorable for me, a neophyte in love with all things animated."

- Michael Sporn, http://www.michaelspornanimation.com/splog/?p=530


" Effects 1969

16mm, color, sound, 2 min

JOHN GATI

A two minute film-study made by the most recent optical-light-shapes technique as art-form. This study also includes techniques of reflected, projected and time-lapse phototgraphed images. All of them designed, built and photographed by John Gati.–J. G.

"This short production is a fine example of an area of creative art on film done without paint pots or paint brushes.

"EFFECTS is a two-minute short, without story content. It is true to its title: EFFECTS... it is abstract forms in constant interplay of rhythmic patterns and radiant colors with an occasional flow-through of a live human form."–Op Cel"


"Emotions At Sunset 1973

16mm, color, sound, 5 min

JOHN GATI

By form, this film is an experiment of mixed cine media. The fusion of live action with abstract self-animated motions, special effects and symbolic scenes. By content, the film's main thought is about happiness. The plot is divided in three parts: illusion, disillision and reality. An experiment of style, where the mixing and super-position of live action with abstract and symbolic animation as emotive expressions obtained successful results.–J. G."

https://film-makerscoop.com/filmmakers/john-gati

"My name is Leslie Bubik Jr. My mom has a sister Edith and Edith married John Gati. An animator, in New York who over time became a very good Animator, I was told. Edith married a Jew and My mom married a Catholic and that is how I have Jewish cousins and relatives, also in New York.


I wish I could find an animator for my software at www.doltware.com My uncle is gone not but he will a well known animator. And He would have done it for me for free. He died a number of years ago. His name was John Gati, in New York. He told me a very interesting story. There was a kid who wanted my Uncle to see his work and he has no idea why it was him this kid kept bugging. My Uncle told me that this kid was persistent and was waiting outside one of his classes as He was also teaching at Cornell University. So my Uncle had a little time and saw this kids stuff. My Uncle was astonished how good it really was. And He is sure that it was not because of him that the kid went forward but it was my Uncles advice that made this kid very happy. Who was the kid??? Spielberg!!! Perhaps Spielberg could help me make a convincing video to help sell my software. Perhaps you know someone who can help me. Interesting true story, I wonder if Spielberg would remember my uncle?"

-Comment from http://mayersononanimation.blogspot.com/2007/02/mickey-mystery.html

"John Gati, Hungarian Film producer and director. Member International Animation Film Association (program director since 1982, journalist festivals since 1980). Born October 6, 1927 Budapest, Hungary. Died July 30, 2002 (aged 74)"

- https://prabook.com/web/john.gati/240912

"GATI-John. Passed away at 7:30PM on Tuesday, July 30, 2002. He was 74 years old. His wife Edith, his sons Paul (a violinist) and William E. (an architect) survive him. He was a violinist, photographer, Holocaust survivor, motion picture producer, director, cinematographer, professor and a great human being. He loved unconditionally and was greatly loved. He felt his greatest achievement was his family and he was a loving and dedicated father and husband.

GATI-John (Janos). The members of the Hungarian Feszek Club mourn the passing of the President of our Board of Directors. He was a respected leader for the Club's goals and ideas."

- New York Times, August 2, 2002, https://web.archive.org/web/20150922145828fw_/http://www.nytimes.com/2002/08/02/classified/paid-notice-deaths-gati-john.html


Cottage Cartoon Industry (published by Taiwan Today, on November 1st 1993) - Cuckoos' Nest, Hung Long, Atlantic Cartoon, Colorkey Productions

  Cottage Cartoon Industry (published by Taiwan Today, on November 1st 1993 ) - https://taiwantoday.tw/news.php?post=25254&unit=20,29...